Warning, these are decadent. And perhaps not a health food. But you can cut them small. But they were a hit of the Christmas party circuit. I recommend freezing or refrigerating them until you are ready to serve them. The inspiration comes from Fine Cooking Magazine’s cookie issue. But they tell you to bake off a shortbread cookie crust first. I didn’t feel like doing that so I repurposed some cookies I had laying around.

What Fine Cooking’s cookies looked like. Mine were pretty close, too. I just didn’t take a photo.
- 1 cup of cookies (Amaratti, pizelles, shortbread cookies, graham crackers–all are good contenders)
- 1 stick of butter (2-3 T for the crust, the rest of the 6 Tbs of butter, softened but not melted f0r the filling)
- 1/2 cup of heavy whipping cream
- 1 bag of chocolate chips
- 1/2 jar of creamy peanut butter (the recipe tells you to use an emulsified butter, such as Jiff. I used organic whole foods creamy peanut butter, and what I realized was that they turn out fine, but they really really need to be cold until serving, or you’ll get a pasty mouthfeel from them. and who wants that? So if you have Skippy or Jiff laying around, or you frequent stores that sell them, go for it. I usually do my shopping where the au natural peanut butter is more common, so that’s what I used)
- 1 1/2 confectioner’s sugar (note you can just blend regular sugar in the blender and get the same texture)
- 1 T vanilla
- a dash of cinnamon
For the crust
- Pre-heat your oven to 350
- Blend up the cookies until they make crumbs
- Pour into a parchment lined 9×9 or 8×8 baking pan
- Cut your butter into pieces and lay on top
- Throw it into the oven for 10 mins
- Mix up your crumbs and let it cool (you can throw it into the freezer while you do the next step)
- The original recipe tells you to use a mixer for this, and perhaps you should. I was too lazy both times I made this and just used a fork to perfectly good results.
- Mix your butter and sugar together until fluffy. Add in your peanut butter and mix.
- Pour the peanut butter mixture over the crust and throw into the freezer while you make the chocolate ganache
- Heat up the cream on medium. When it bubbles and is hot, add in your chocolate chips. Lower the heat to simmer and stir constantly until it makes a smooth, shiny ganache. Pour over your now cold peanut butter. Return the pan to the freezer for a half hour or to the fridge for at least an hour.
- Cut into small squares. I put each square into a cupcake liner.
- Enjoy. mmm….peanut butter. chocolate.